- Anthony Frausto-Robledo ([email protected])
- 29 Aug 2002
Opinion: Newton X: Why Apple needs to go this way
A story on Wired today discussed the Apple Newton PDA and its vigorous user community...a collection of users (numbering over 20,000) worldwide who continue to stand by Apple's defunct granddaddy of the PDA world. The Newton was and remains today -- as these users will remind you -- the best PDA on the planet. Regardless, Apple killed the Newton platform so that Apple could focus all its resources on Mac OS X.
The memory of this computer reminds me of why Apple should have never gotten rid of it in the first place. Besides having some of the most passionate and intelligent PDA users and programmers in the world, the Newton itself had the absolute best handwriting recognition software to be found anywhere. Ironically, Mac OS X Jaguar now has that same handwriting recognition software. Moreover, Apple's OS X programmers have likely improved it a bit.
What Prematurely Kills May Give You New Life
Some say what killed the Newton was the product's premature introduction. Some say specifically it was the initially poor handwriting recognition software. But this handwriting recognition engine got much better over time, and today lives as Inkwell in Mac OS X Jaguar.
I say what killed the product can give it new life. You see, the Newton had (and still has) something no other PDA has ever been able to match: a unique combination of raw power (in its RISC ARM chip), powerful Newton OS, and huge screen. The form-factor of the Newton is unique.
Those combinations made it a favorite in vertical industries like medicine, field engineering services, retail, and science. The product is ideal for architects as well -- its sketching abilities captured the essence of the architect's famous 'napkin sketch'.
Why The Newton Should Come Back
The Newton should come back to challenge Microsoft's Tablet PC initiatives and fill a void that will ensue when the PDA industry merges with the cell phone market to become the "smart phone". Precisely because there is inevitable convergence with the PDA and cell phone, the resulting products will create a vacuum which can be (and should be) filled. Microsoft would love to fill this vacuum with Windows-driven tablets of all sizes. But Apple and its many allies shouldn't let them do that for all the obvious reasons.
Newton Was Always a Tablet
The Newton was destined to be a tablet device. In fact, there were originally two Newton teams in the beginning, each with a different philosophy for the new personal digital assistant. One team envisioned something very small (like the Palm Pilot). The other team saw the new device as something larger (not too far from Microsoft's Tablet PC). What resulted was a compromise called the Newton.
If Steve Jobs was back at Apple then things could have ended up differently for the first Newton. But history is over and its time for new action.
An Apple Open-Source Tablet Architecture Initiative (Newton X)
Apple should create an open-source tablet architecture initiative. Such an initiative could help thwart the Microsoft Tablet PC, provide a place to go for the Newton community, and allow Apple the chance to experience a true 'open-source' experience without any financial threat to its main business.
It has become obvious and clear that Apple has no intentions of coming out with a Palm-OS based PDA device or one that uses a Mac OS X Lite operating system. Jobs has stated that the PDA will morph into the smart phone. Some speculate that Apple will come out with iPhone in the next year and that it will be a device that reinvents what a smart phone should be like.
Additionally, Apple is slowly turning the iPod into a multipurpose device, replete with traditional PDA responsibilities. One could easily imagine Apple taking the iPod so far as to make it that one device we use for all things (music, portable hard drive, PDA, cell phone, communications, and even video player). Such a device has been called the ultra personal computer or UPC. Such a device lives at our side...a constant companion. And naturally it will tend towards the small.
Size Does Matters
Where Apple can go with Newton X is up in scale. Starting with the last generation Newton as a starting point, such new larger Newtons could evolve into a pure tablet play and play to the original Newton's strengths in the vertical markets.
Vertical Industries and Open-Source
These vertical industries are ideal for open-source and the Newton developer community had some of the brightest and most creative programmers anywhere in the world.
As a starting point, Apple could take the majority of the Newton OS code and turn it into open-source project. Second, it could create a reference platform based around the prevalent mobile device microprocessor architectures: ARM's StrongARM (RISC) chips and Intel's new XScale. With Arm's upcoming mobile chip 3D visualization initiatives, such an open-source tablet reference design could emerge as a viable gaming platform for wireless gamers who need the larger screens for advanced 3D games.
Newton X devices as variably sized tablet computers are ideal for scientists, doctors, nurses, engineers in the field, field services personnel, retail, shipping, warehousing, education customers, contractors and architects, artists who work outside, and all users whose primary work involves mobility, the outdoors, and pen input functions like drawing.
Newton X itself could be rewritten by the open-source community around the same Darwin core and Mach kernel, with the potential for a Linux kernel development. By keeping the reference design UNIX/Linux-based, Apple can be assured that Macs will be ideal connectivity partners to Newton X devices. And the users listed above happen to be many of the current target users for Mac OS X, especially scientists and engineers, architects and educational customers.
The question really is: can Apple and the rest of the industry afford to allow Microsoft to take over the emerging tablet computing market unchallenged?
Microsoft will discover that the tablet market has legs. Pen-input computing will only advance further as handwriting recognition and voice recognition improve towards perfection. The PDA market is dead as we know it. It will evolve into the 'smart phone' or what Handspring calls the "communicator" (what it calls its superb Treo line) and this market will distill down to a particular optimal form factor with tiny keyboard and voice input options.
But the smart phone can never fulfill the needs of industries which originally turned to the Newton. Those industries need larger screens and they don't need keyboards per se; they need superb wired and wireless communications. And they need superb programmers. These are all things the Newton platform provided. With the cell phone and PDA market all headed in one very competitive and distinct direction, nobody is watching the vacuum that is being created by that movement. Except for Microsoft. And if they go unchallenged, they will soon dominate the larger (Newton form-factor) tablet computer market and use it as leverage into its neighboring markets: smart phone, laptop, and even traditional PDA market, which will likely become more valuable to the K-12 education market.
To prevent that we need Newton X.
For questions and feedback, write to Anthony at: [email protected]
Anthony Frausto-Robledo, B.Arch., is the founder and editor of the award-winning Architosh.com Web site. Educated as an architect, he has been an architectural professional for over 17 years and was a senior designer with the distinguished Boston architectural firm Koetter Kim & Associates prior to launching his web consultancy, BritasMedia. As president of BritasMedia, Anthony consults AEC firms on strategic Web initiatives, animation, databases, and IT-related issues in addition to publishing the Architosh site daily. Since 1997 he has been a member of the Thesis Studio and History & Theory faculty at the Boston Architectural Center College of Architecture and Interior Design and a Thesis Advisor.
BritasMedia's publishing mission with the Architosh Website is to serve a worldwide audience of Macintosh-based CAD/3D and AEC professionals with market-leading information technology (IT) resources, news and editorial products. Architosh currently serves over 25,000 readers monthly in more than 70 countries around the world.
Apple G5: Smokes Intel Competition
Apple, Autodesk and Mac OS X
ProSwitcher: Joe Esch: SketchUp, Cocoa and Mac OS X
Bill Gates' House Designed on Macintosh?
Macworld Expo San Francisco 2006
MWSF: CAD Industry Puts Positive Spin on Apple-Intel Partnerships and New Mactels - [17
MWSF: VersaCAD and TurboCAD at Macworld - Updated Notes from the Show Floor - [17 Jan]
MWSF: VectorWorks Plays Role in Swiss 'Inventioneering Architecture' Exhibit - [17 Jan]
MWSF: SketchUp Used in Golden Globe Award Nominated Film - [17 Jan]
MWSF: Architosh's Expo Photos 1 - [14 Jan]
MWSF: Architosh's Expo
Photos 2 - [14 Jan]
MWSF: Architosh's Expo
Photos 3 - [14 Jan]
MWSF: Architosh's Expo
Photos 4 - [14 Jan]
MWSF: Architosh's Expo
Photos 5 - [14 Jan]
MWSF: SketchUp News at Macworld Expo - [13 Jan]
MWSF: AEC Software Industry Highlights - [11 Jan]
MWSF: Jobs' Keynote - The Highlights 4 - [11 Jan]
MWSF: Jobs' Keynote -
The Highlights 3 - [11 Jan]
MWSF: Jobs' Keynote -
The Highlights 2 - [10 Jan]
MWSF: Jobs' Keynote - The Highlights - [10 Jan]
Features & News
3d: MAXON announces CINEMA 4D for Intel-based Macs - [7 Feb]
Mac 3d: MAXON announces CINEMA 4D for Intel-based Macs - [30 Jan]
Mac CAD: ArchiCAD meets structural design - [27 Jan]
Mac CAD: Microspot Interiors v.3.6 now shipping - [27 Jan]
AEC News: Adobe announces Acrobat 3D - [23 Jan] Hot!
Adobe talks to Architosh about Acrobat 3D and the Mac - [23 Jan] Hot!
Acrobat 3D: Methods of 3D Data Integration - [23 Jan]
Architosh to publish 'double-issue' ToshLetter in February - [19 Jan]
Mac CAD: VectorWorks user wins Miami Monument International Design Competition - [19 Jan]
Mac CAD: Free VectorWorks 12 Viewer Now Available - [4 Jan]
Tidbits: Mac CAD/3d/AEC news - PandaWare, SIGGRAPH and Quad Mac Rendering Support - [4 Jan]
Intel's new logo revealed - good enough for Apple's new computers? - [3 Jan]
2006: Intel Betting on Apple in Digital Home Convergence? - [30 Dec] Hot!
Apple Developers Ready for Intel - Possible New Macs at Macworld Expo - [30 Dec] Hot!
Apple Adds More Online Seminars for Architects - [29 Dec] Hot!
Mac CAD: First CAD Developer Announces Upcoming Support for Intel Macs with Current Product Version - [21 Dec]
Mac GIS: OpenOSX announces "Grass WorkFlow Pro" - [20 Dec]
Apple Seminar: Working with Autocad DWG on the Mac - [20 Dec] Hot!
Macworld Prediction: Apple to come out with new Pod Studio - [16 Dec] Hot!
Mac 3d: RenderCore's RenMan Client for Mac OS X in development - [16
Mac 3d: New photorealistic scenary rendering software for Mac OS X - Terragen 2 Technology Preview - [16
Mac 3d: Dosch 3D Ships Set Sail - [14 Dec]
CS Odessa updates ConceptDraw V for Mac OS X - [14 Dec]
AEC News: Web-based Project Management software for Mac OS X - Copper 2005 - [14
Mac 3d: What comes after NURBS? Modeling the Future - [13 Dec] Hot!
First Technical Drawing Program Readied for Upcoming Intel-based Macs - [8 Dec] Hot!
Mac 3d: Nemetschek N. A. releases free SketchUp plugin for VectorWorks - [6 Dec]
Mac CAD: VectorWorks 12 Training CDs Now Available - [5 Dec]
Mac CAD: ArchiCAD Seminar in Boston Area - [5
Apple's Global Architecture Resources Grow - [1 Dec] Hot!
Mac 3d: EVOQUE launches "solidThinking Live" - new web training program - [28 Nov]
Apple Sales this Holiday Quarter and Special Friday Event - [23 Nov]
Mac 3d: Adobe and Cinema 4D Breakfast Event in Sweden - [23
Mac CAD: VectorWorks Users win AIA-NYC and AIA-NYS Design Awards - [22 Nov]
Tidbits: CAD and 3d roundup - SOM and SketchUp, Alex, and MaxonForm - [21 Nov]
Mac CAD: HighDesign 1.6 released - dozens of improvements - [17 Nov]
Commentary: Virtualization from Intel in future Macs and the Art of Fast User Switching - [16 Nov]
Tidbits: Mac AEC News on the Web - ATI, ProjectWizards update and more... - [15 Nov]
ATI introduces world's fastest graphics card - [11 Nov]
Wrap-up: Mac CAD - Graphisoft Honored with Wall Street Journal Award and more... -
Technology Behind Apple's Rosetta Wins Wall Street Journal 2005 Technology Award -
Mac 3d: Alias Introduces 'Design MasterClasses' -
Mac 3d: Pixar debuts RenderMan for Maya - [9 Nov]
Tidbits: Apple patent shows company possibly preparing for OS War - [8 Nov]
Architosh Ships First Issue of ToshLetter™ - [4 Nov]
ArchiCAD Gets 'Sketchy' with new SketchUp Integration - [1 Nov]
Mac CAD: Nemetschek NA ships VectorWorks 12 - [1 Nov]
Apple Fixes Missing Graphics Card on e Store - [28 Oct]
Wrap-Up: Mac CAD/3D news on the Web - Cheetah, Adobe-UGS, ArchiCAD and more... -
Mac CAD: ArchiCAD 9 Seminar in Providence, Rhode Island - [26 Oct]
Mac 3D: Pixar to announce Third Quarter 2005 Earnings, November 8th -
New Power Mac G5 Quad Garners Industry Buzz - [21 Oct] Hot!
Quad Supercharges Rendering by 200 Plus Percent: a modo reaction -
New Nvidia Workstation Option, When it Matters -
The New Power Mac G5s - Initial Thoughts -
Mac CAD: True Workstation Graphics Finally Arrive on the Macintosh -
Mac CAD: Share Utility - How to share Ashlar-Vellum Files, both Old and New - [18 Oct]
Frank Lloyd Wright's Massaro House Presentation Available - Architect Talks up Working on Macintosh Platform - [17 Oct]
Mac CAD: Ashlar-Vellum translates 'Graphite' into Japanese -
Mac CAD: Nemetschek announces VectorWorks 12 Product Line - [13 Oct]
Mac CAD: Graphisoft Scores Firm Win in California - [7 Oct]
SketchUp News: @Last Software Previews New "Grizzly" at 3D Base Camp - [6 Oct] Hot!
Mac CAD: TouchCAD 3.5 Becomes "Touchable" At Last - [5 Oct]
High Impact: Autodesk to acquire Alias - what does it mean? - [5 Oct] Hot!
Exclusive Interview: Architosh Talks to Graphisoft US VP Don R. Henrich II - [4 Oct] Hot!
Special Series: Apple-Intel Transition to be Positive for CAD/CAID/AEC Developers and Their Users - [4
Architosh Show Reports Index - [4 Oct]
Architosh introduces ToshLetter™ a new industry newsletter focused on Mac CAD/3D industries - [30 Sep] Hot!
Mac 3D: e-frontier's new Shade 8 modeling and rendering program - [28 Sep]
Mac CAD: Ashlar-Vellum releases Graphite service pack 2 - [28
Mac 3D: Maxwell plugin for SketchUp on Mac - [27 Sep]
Mac 3D: Alias ships MotionBuilder 7 PLE - [27
Tidbits: Mac 3d and CAD news - SketchUp, Maxwell, EIAS, Softimage - [27
VectorWorks User Wins Venice Biennale's International Design Competition - [20 Sep]
New Mac Firm Management Software Tool for Architects and Engineers - PSA Scorecard - [16 Sep]
ForumTalk: Macintosh CAD Discussion - PowerCADD, BOA for Mac OS X Roadmap, Piranesi and more... - [16 Sep]
Macintosh World Gains New Engineering CAD Tool with IMSI TurboCAD 3D Mac - [14 Sep]
Mac 3d: T-Splines 1.0 plugin for Alias Maya now available -
Mac CAD/3D: SketchUp at Apple Expo, formZ News and MacroEnter Fall CAD Specials - [13 Sep]
CAD News: IntelliCAD 6.1 announced, IMSI TurboCAD 3D for Mac OS X listed on Academic Software Store - [9 Sep]
Mac 3D: Cheetah 3D 2.4 now available - [8 Sep]
Press Release: Architosh to launch new industry newsletter with focus on Macintosh CAD/3D professionals and software developers - [2 Sep]
Wrap-Up: Mac CAD/3D News on the Web - VectorWorks, Entourage Arts, CADtools, and more... - [2 Sep]
Mac CAD: Hot Door Adds CAD Power to Familiar Adobe Illustrator Application - [2
Mac 3D: Entourage Arts Announces New Landscape Collections, Tap Power of SketchUp 5 - [2 Sep]
Mac CAD: French Developers Push BOA Towards OS X Version, US Website Closes - [29 Aug] Hot!
Mac CAD: ArchiCAD Presentation (Live Webcast) on Frank Lloyd Wright 'Massaro' House - Modeled and Documented on the Macintosh - [26 Aug] Hot!
ForumTalk: Macintosh CAD Topics - Wind Modeling in 3D, Chinese Characters in VectorWorks and TurboCAD - [26
Mac CAD: Boston AIA VectorWorks User Meeting to Feature Nemetschek Tech Session - [19 Aug] Hot!
Mac CAD/3d: VersaCAD/SketchUp Bundle Available from Archway Systems - [19 Aug]
Open Design Alliance Philosophy Promotes Proper Ownership of CAD Datat to Users, Not Software Companies - [19
Mac CAD: TurboCAD Targets UK Market via new Mac OS X Product - [16 Aug]
Apple CAD: Apple Stores Targeting CAD Customers with more products - [16
Macintosh CAD Weekly Wrapup: Nemetschek VectorWorks Training and More... - [12 Aug] Hot!
MidWeek Update: Mac CAD and 3D News: Apple VAR Focuses on CAD Store, ArchiCAD Nabs Award - [10 Aug]
Mac 3d: SketchUp News - 3D Base Camp - [10
Graphisoft gets specific in satisfying customer's needs in ArchiCAD 9 Special Edition Library - [28 July]
Mac 3D: LightWork Design releases more accuracy in its range of GE Advanced Materials, Plastics -
Autodesk Clears its Deck for Huge Upgrade -
Pre-SIGGRAPH: "Kuriocity" by Luminetik Animation Studios to premier at SIGGRAPH - [25 July] Hot!
Gee...tiny pictures of documents themselves in lieu of icons, who would have thunk it possible with Windows Vista? - [25
OS Wars: New Windows Vista name announced, users cry Longhorn already five years behind - [25
Mac CAD: Apple grows market share, various indices show Apple gaining back biz customers in AEC - [20 July] Hot!
Wrap-up: Mac CAD/3d news on the Web - SketchUp 5, Vue 5 Infinite, Ashlar-Vellum and more.. - [15 July]
Mac CAD: Nemetschek updates VectorWorks to v11.5.1 -
Apple Earnings: FindProfit.com Examines Implications of Apple's Earnings Report -
SketchUp is Finally Elaborated Into SketchUp 5, New Training Tour Announced - [14 July] Hot!
Mac 3d: Ashlar Delays Release of the V7 Builds, Company Builds Much Anticipation -
Mac 3d: NewTek and E-On Unleash their priced Duo: Vue 5 Infinite & LightWave 3D -
[14 July] Hot!
Freshly released version 7.9 Creative Manager Pro Expands Borders - [13 July]
In Brief: Wentworth Institute of Technology gets "Vectorized" on the Macintosh - [12 July]
In Brief: Pixar to announce Second Quarter Earnings, August 4th, during SIGGRAPH week - [8 July]
Commentary: New dual-core Power Macs timed for Apple's Return to SIGGRAPH - [8 July]
Commentary: IBM announces new dual-core G5 - [8 July]
Wrap-up: Mac CAD/3d news on the web: VectorWorks prize, Maxwell, ArchiCAD and more - [8 July]
Mac CAD: Graphisoft adds 'industry-first' integrated organic modeling to Virtual Building technology -
Mac CAD: VectorWorks Design Competition Grand Prize Winner Announced -
Mac 3d: Maxwell is new photo-realistic rendering program for Mac OS X users - [7 July] Hot!
Home > Features > News